ChristmasEasterHalloweenHogmanaySt Andrew’s DaySt David’s DaySt Patrick’s DayValentines
Home • Recipe • School Cake
Published by Amy
When I first set out to make this recipe I wondered if School Cake was now a thing of the past. The boys however informed me that you do still indeed get School Cake at lunchtime, albeit not everyday, nor after a ‘nutritious’ serving of Turkey Twizzlers and chips!
School dinners are something that seems to have a generational divide. For me, a child of the 90s, school dinners were pizza, Turkey Twizzlers, Turkey Drumsticks & Turkey Dinosaurs (basically a lot of turkey!), plenty chips and buckets of beans.
Granny remembers mince, stew, cold meats, sausages and fish pie, all served with potatoes and veg – never chips!
And the boys school dinners these days are made up of macaroni, fajitas, bubble fish, stir-fries, steak pie and lots of fruit & veg on the side.
One thing that is always a hit at school dinners, regardless of what generation you are from, is School Cake! Instantly recognisable, this basic sponge is topped with a layer of icing and a generous amount of sprinkles. And that’s literally it…nothing overly fancy but delicious enough to have an entire dinner hall of kids buzzing with excitement and praying there will be at least enough until their spot in the line.
MargarineSimilar to our Victoria Sponge recipe, we recommend using margarine over butter for your cake batter. Some believe butter gives a better flavour overall to a cake, but margarine does make a better textured and more predictable sponge. Plus, it’s pretty much guaranteed that any actual school cake would have been made using margarine – mostly because it’s more cost effective than butter.As with all ingredients when baking a sponge cake, ensure it is at room temperature before starting.
Caster SugarNo one said School Cake was healthy and the sweetness is probably why we all love it so! Caster sugar is the sugar of choice here and is preferable over granulated sugar, as it is finer and mixes better into the batter.
Free-range EggsFive eggs seems like a lot but this is a big cake! The size of the eggs doesn’t matter too much (I always use medium) but just be sure you’re using free-range eggs.As with all ingredients when baking a sponge cake, ensure they are at room temperature before starting.
Self-raising FlourAgain, flour is a must in a cake batter and self-raising is used here to allow it to rise. No additional raising agents are required but be sure to sift the flour.
Icing Sugar and SprinklesTo give your School Cake that iconic finish of white icing, topped with rainbow sprinkles!
• Bake your sponge the night before you require it. Leave it in it’s grease proof paper, on a wire rack and place into a air-tight bag once cool. Decorate with the icing and sprinkles in the morning. This will give your cake a better texture overall – trust me!
Excellent and very easy cake to make, and enjoyed in and out of school!!
As a first time baker of school cake i have to say it’s an really easy recipe, and it tastes good, i had 4 medium sized eggs instead of 5. And it worked out well. A family member had used the oven before me, so it only had to be in for 25 minutes. So be sure to check on the cake.
We have never had a school dinner being from Australia, however this was delicious and so quick to put together. We demolished it warm, without any icing as it was sweet enough for us.
I Made Chocolate School dinner Cake on Saturday 6th March 2021. It was very easy to Make.
What did you change to make the chocolate one?
I remember having a Chocolate School Dinner Cake
Just add choc powder. I use mint custard with choc cake. That’s how we did it in our school kitchen.
Can I have recipe
Zoe…a please would be nice. Manners cost nothing.
Absolutely delicious, I’m usually a terrible cook but even my husband gave me the thumbs up. Very easy to make, even easier to eat!!
Simple and effective, all the family enjoyed making and eating this cake.
Insists on… margarine, then insists on free-range eggs?!
Not actually a contradiction!
Butter is a “richer” ingredient because of its composition and it doesn’t work in some ingredients as well, it ruins them in the same way marg isn’t suitable for some.
Butter is made mostly of milk/cream itself whereas margarine is diluted with rapeseed oil usually which changes how it works.
Free range eggs are the best eggs because they are the healthiest given they are coming from chicken that have been given the best chance also a free life.
It’s not about the cost at all but a combination of the composition and the quality.
I hope it makes to you.
Haven’t tried the recipe yet but the name got me thinking of Studenterbrød (student bread) from Denmark. It”s more dense and fudgy and a large part of it is made from leftover pastries and/or cake that are no longer worth selling. It was considered a cheap cake option for students in the old days.
Yuuuuuum, this is such a delicious recipe! The recipe size makes a really big traycake which stays moist (but it hasn’t lasted very long in our household- its so moreish!). Great, easy, foolproof recipe
This recipe was really easy to follow. The ingredients are things you should already have lying about the house. I only made half of the recipe to test it out. It was delicious and the cake was really light, with or without icing! It will go really well with custard ! A new favourite for sure! :)
How many eggs did you use when you halved this recipe, please?
Just use 2 eggs and 2 tablespoons of milk
Such a good recipe, so easy to follow and remember. Overall, I love this site and it’s my go to as a baking granny who only discovered the joys of home baking during the Covid lockdowns.
The school cake is such a winner and makes me very nostalgic for Scottish school dinners which always included a pudding!
Thank you Amy and family xx
Is the margarine salted?
hi what ingredeants did u youse as im going to be bakeing all the way throuh lock down to insure my fambily like my bakeing xxxxxxxxxxx
Hi how can I change the school cake into a chocolate version please
Just make your mixture and add cocoa powder to it thats how you turn a cake into a chocolate cake.
No Leanne dear, it is not. If you just do that you are altering the structure first remove a couple of tablespoons of flour and then add the same of cocoa powder, and sift together, if you want to be really fussy, temper the cocoa powder spoon for spoon with hot water and add it to the butter sugar mix.
Just make your mixture and add cocoa powder to it thats how you turn a cake into a chocolate cake.
Well in fairy buns it’s normal 75g of flour and 25g Cocoa powder. So you can work it out for this recipe. Hope that helps
Just add cocoa powder to it
The first time I’ve ever successfully baked a cake!!!!! This recipe is fantastic
Excellent School Cake Pudding . I remember having Jam on top.
Sprinkle coconut over the jam for a nice alternative
My grand children love this cake,
I added vanilla bean paste.. yum!
Hello, I am wanting to make this cake for my mum’s birthday in a few days as she has been wanting to try it. How many does this recipe serve? Also, if I were to half it, how many eggs would I use since 5 doesn’t half equally. Many thanks :)
Sorry, I just found that the servings are listed above. Although I still have the question about the eggs. Thanks again :)
Hi Leah rose, You could crack 5 eggs int a jug and whisk use half for the cake and make an omelette with the rest. All the best.
Well, I would have been faffing about trying to halve the recipe. This is the perfect way. Scrambled eggs for breakfast tomorrow! Thank you, Rab!
Hi Leah, I would use two large eggs for half the mixture. I found 5 eggs quite a lot, but they were larger medium eggs if you know what I mean. Lovely recipe
Use 2 eggs and 2 tablespoons milk replace 2 tablespoons of flour with cocoa powder for a chocolate version
Can this cake be left in the fridge overnight? I am wanting to bake it the day before it is going to be served, but I don’t want to leave it out as it is a surprise for my Mum’s birthday and I do not want her to see it. Many thanks :)
Yes it can leave in the bag though or covered with cling film
Governor Jones! Has a nice ring to it
Good cake, but could be a bit more descriptive of a recipe, such as what size eggs etc.
Hi, Can you freeze this after making? It tastes so nice, very reminiscent of my school days! Many thanks
SO GOOD I love ittttt tastes really nice initially I thought 5 eggs sounds a bit off but it taste really good and not eggy at all
This cake is absolutely amazing my family and I enjoyed this very much ! You must try this recipe
Amazing cake recipe. I’ve also done a chocolate version just add 60g of bournville coco powder .
If you add 60g of cocoa powder then you should take out 60g of flour
Great memories from my primary school dinner’s, i haven’t made it yet, but i have decided to bake this for my son’s birthday cake.
Love this recipe and sooo delicious. Do you reckon I could do this recipe but into cupcakes? X
could you use oil instead of margarine?
Cooked and tasted fabulous
I would like to thank you and Kitchen Sanctuary with out your help I would have not been , able to pass my course and Annie Low .. I enjoyed baking School Cake it didn’t have sprinkles so I used chocalate flakes on top just done it today taste braw. My regard s from yhe Cheeky Baker.
Can you make the batter a day in advance if kept refrigerated over night and air tight wrapped? TIA
Reminded me of my old school lunches was yummy and actually tasted just like school if not better!!!!
Made cake but instead of icing put jam and desiccated coconut on top
Nice and moist but not enough mixture so a little flat on the edges. I would add another 100g on all ingredients.
Perhaps your baking tray was a wee bit bigger than recipe given
JUST LIKE SCHOOL CAKE! Absolutely loved this and was so easy to follow
Turned out perfectly – lovely rise on it too Now they want me to make It all the time
My husband loves these and I put coconut as well as sprinkles on the top . He is a big kid aged 75!
Best one i’ve ever made
Looks great takes great
Amazing recipe, just made this for the Grandchildren, a big hit.
Wonderful old school sweet treats.
Absolutely phenomenal! I waited ages to make this and when I did it turned out perfect So simple in its parts but was exactly what I craved. Thankyou for the school days throwback
Loved making this cake, and yes used to have it at my school. Can’t wait to try it. Recipe so easy to follow.
I made the cake for the first time and it was delicious. I did make some changes instead of margerine I used clover light butter and instead of 280g caster sugar I used 160g it was still great. The icing sugar I also did not use as much and was 260-280g. I shared it with my Grandma and partner they all said it was nice. I am going to make my second one soon. Thank you so much for the boiling water technique to make the Icing plus sifting the flour that I forgot!
In my oven now can’t wait to taste to bring back all those memories of school dinner used to be served with what I think was a water based custard but not 100% sure on that but I do remember it was delicious. I am topping mine with Raspberry jam and rolled icing I think it will work well.
I’m yet to make this, can I use golden caster sugar?
I am trying this recipe out later today but can you freeze once made?
Beautiful delicious cake and easy to make and serve. But how do I prevent the icing falling off on the second day when I’m cutting the remainder of the cake?
The link for the tin size to Amazon isn’t right, takes you to a electric heater – just thought I’d let you know
Got a question? Tried this recipe & want to leave some feedback? Please use the comment section below! Required fields are marked *
This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.
Hello, I’m Amy, the voice-behind and creator-of Baking with Granny.
Join over 20k other bakers and subscribe to my FREE email list.